Attention to each order
Better Closing Experiences for Everyone
Our people-first approach has made Mutual Title one of the best title agencies in Ohio, Michigan, Indiana, Pennsylvania, DC, Florida, Maryland, Virginia, Tennessee, New Jersey, North Carolina, Missouri, Wisconsin, Illinois, and Minnesota.
What we do
Your single stop for complete title services
Title Examinations
Title Commitments
Owner/Lender Title Insurance
Notary Services
Property Profiles
Escrow and Closing Services
Our Story

Your full-service title agency, from start to closing.
Buying a home is a dream for many people. Closing, however, can seem complicated. Mutual Title Agency was founded in 2004 to change that.
Our people-focused philosophy means we deliver title and escrow closing experiences that put people — homebuyers, sellers, real estate agents and loan officers — first. We’re fast. We’re thorough. We keep each party on the same page with status updates and a proactive approach to issue resolution, from start to close.
Why? So we can make closing on real estate the high note it should be.

The Mutual Title Difference
Title services you can count on.
Average days to close
Customer Satisfaction
Meet our Team
Our team is your team
With more than a century of experience under our belts, the Mutual Title team uses our expertise to deliver seamless experiences that take the stress out of closing. Here’s who you’ll meet along the way:

Kim Croftcheck
President
kcroftcheck@mutualtitleagency.com
440-816-1800

Beth Dzurilla
Sales Manager
bdzurilla@mutualtitleagency.com
330-348-4133

Dominic Corstange
Sales Representative
dcorstange@mutualtitleagency.com
616-648-4534

Mary Ann Finnegan
Title Officer
mafinnegan@mutualtitleagency.com
440-297-2467

Jen Emerson
Escrow Officer
jemerson@mutualtitleagency.com
440-297-2470

Stacey Gonzales
Escrow Officer
sgonzales@mutualtitleagency.com
616-209-3866

Katrina Lee
Escrow Officer
440-975-7859

Cathy Seneff
Escrow Officer
440-214-7135

Lilliana Rivera
Disbursement Coordinator
lillianarivera@mutualtitleagency.com
216-236-7316

You!
We're always looking for great talent. Send your resume to:
Get Started
Ready to Start Closing? So are we.
Submit your title order online and we'll take you across the finish. Have questions? Let's chat.